This website uses features that your browser doesn't support. Please upgrade to a recent version of your browser.

Please cite as: DURARE Project (Marjolijn Bol, Jan van Daal, Grace Kim-Butler, Henrike Scholten, and Clara Mikellides de Chiaro) and Giacomo Montanari. 2023. "Hands-On with Textile Mordants: More than Meets the Eye." Last updated: 1 November 2023. https://story.durare.eu/hands-on-with-textile-mordants.

Media
  • DURARE





Hands-On with Textile Mordants: More than Meets the Eye

A collaboration between AlchemEast and DURARE in the Utrecht University's ArtLab.















Please cite as: DURARE Project (Marjolijn Bol, Jan van Daal, Grace Kim-Butler, Henrike Scholten, and Clara Mikellides de Chiaro) and Giacomo Montanari. 2023. "Hands-On with Textile Mordants: More than Meets the Eye." Last updated: 1 November 2023. https://story.durare.eu/hands-on-with-textile-mordants.

Between a textile and its dye often lies a crucial material hidden from view: the mordant. Mordants can be made out of many materials, but they all help fix the dye to the fabric, making its colors more resistant to wear, washing, and sunlight. On the matter of the durability of dyed textiles, we found, there is more than meets the eye.

Imagine rinsing a piece of clothing only for most of its color to wash away. When we put on clothes or pick out a new fabric, we rarely think about the unseen chemical processes that shape how a fabric's color behaves over time. Mordants work to enhance the durability of the dyed fabric by establishing a chemical bond between a fabric and its dye.

This French manuscript illumination from De Proprietatibus rerum ("On the Properties of Things") by Bartholomew of England depicts the dyeing of fabric in the 15th century. Mordants would have been used in the dye bath to make the dye adhere more permanently to the fabric.

This 17th-century Dutch print depicts a dyer pulling up cloth from a furnace designed to dye textiles. In the background, workers rinse out the cloth in a river or canal.

The verse below the print explains that the "pale woolen cloth" is uniformly soaked through with dye to be "reborn", analogous to how Christ's blood soaks people's souls "to please the Eternal Eye."

Mordants enabled dyers to impart uniform color on textiles. They were also used to hand-paint long-lasting, intricate designs, such as this elaborate Indian export cloth (made around 1675-1725 for the Japanese market) depicting figures, plants, and architecture.

Sources of Mordants

Today's handbooks for dyeing at home recommend the same mordanting materials found in recipes from antiquity to the early modern period. They range from rusty nails (a source of iron) to the husks of walnuts (a source of tannin). We worked with a selection of these mordants to bring them into focus.

The DURARE team was joined by chemist Giacomo Montanari, research fellow in the FARE project "AlchemEast in the West" (University of Bologna). Over three days, our ArtLab was transformed into a makeshift dyeing workshop.

In recent years, dyers, chemists, and textile historians have become more interested in the behavior of mordants. We explored how experimenting with mordants could facilitate an interdisciplinary discussion.

Here we describe our experiment as it unfolded in the lab and provide a glimpse into the insights, discussions, and little surprises that bubbled to the surface as we worked together.

Our Materials

We selected three natural fabrics to mordant and dye for our experiment. From left to right, you see untreated regular weave cotton fabric and two types of raw silk: a silk crepe produced by cultivated silk worms and so-called tussah silk produced by wild silk worms.









The mordants in our experiment fell into one of two categories: metallic or plant-derived. Because of the differences in their chemical composition, these mordants form different molecular bonds with dyes and fabrics. Metallic mordants form coordination complexes, while plant-derived mordants form hydrogen bond networks.

The strength of these bonds also depends on the fabric, such as whether it is plant-derived (like cotton) or animal-derived (like silk).

Aluminous rock is first mined, and then heated and purified to form alum, which can be used as a metallic mordant.

Each type of fabric was soaked in heated mordant baths. We used three metallic mordants: (left) iron(II) sulfate, (center) potassium aluminum sulfate, also known as alum, and (right) copper sulfate.

The mortars in this picture show our plant-derived mordants: (left) walnut husks, (center) crushed oak galls, and (right) dried rhubarb roots.

We used a single dyestuff to explore the effects of our mordants in the dyeing process: weld (Reseda luteola). The flowers of this plant yield a yellow dye. Across the world, dyers have worked with weld since the first millennium BC.

Our Experiment

1. We began by heating and preparing our mordant baths.

2. Then we cut our textiles into small samples.

3. Next, we soaked the samples in our mordant baths for two hours.

4. We laid the pieces of mordanted textiles out to dry.

5. We extracted the yellow dye from the weld by soaking it in warm water.

6. The plant material was filtered out to create a dye solution.

7. We soaked half of the mordanted textiles in heated dye baths for two hours.

8. Once the textiles were dry, we compared the undyed mordanted samples to the mordanted samples that we had dyed.



'Mordant' Meets the Eye

The process of hands-on work with mordants engaged our senses. Discussing these sensory experiences helped create common ground for conversation across our respective disciplines.

The chalkboard shows how we structured our discussion, such as how the texture of silk changed before and after mordanting or how each mordant had its own distinct color.

The senses

Before the workshop we had recognized a mordant's ability to act as an invisible glue that fixes dye to textile. Yet working with mordants showed that they, too, have their very own sensorial qualities and influence on the end result. Seeing the mordants gathered together on our lab table, we noticed that they were crisp blue or lush green powders. Some mordants had an earthy scent; others looked like objects you could find in a forest.

This visibility carried over in how the mordants affected the appearance of the fabric samples, before and after dyeing. Using a single dye, weld, opened our eyes to the ranges of hues you can produce, simply by experimenting with different mordants.

Colors of metallic mordants

This is the end result of the metallic mordants, side by side with the dyed fabrics.

Already after soaking our fabrics in the different mordants, they took on a a range of colors. As you see here, iron turned the fabric a subtle taupe, alum maintained the natural appearance of the fabric and copper yielded a light turquoise.

Colors of plant-derived mordants

The plant-derived substances yielded a range of yellows and browns. While the difference in the end color was quite dramatic between the different metallic mordants, the color nuances between the cloths treated with plant-based mordants were more subtle.

We noticed that the different metallic and plant-derived substances all came with different working properties even beyond color.

While rinsing excess mordant off the textiles, we realized that the mordants changed how they repelled water and how the fabrics felt on our skin. If a mordant can be valued for bringing about a specific hue, perhaps it can also be valued for how it makes a fabric feel.

Interdisciplinary Bonds

We came together to examine the role of mordants in the dyeing process and explore the skills required when working with them. Rather than coming together to investigate a chemical formula or a historical recipe, for instance, we chose for the material substance of the mordants to center our collaboration.

Mordanting well?

This collaborative experiment enabled us to reframe the question of ''mordanting well.''

We came to this experiment with implicit assumptions about mordants. As we worked, we made these assumptions more explicit, with each of us evaluating the quality of the mordants and the mordanting process differently.

We considered mordants chemicals organized by purity and origin, a practical means to dye durably, or a research source on historical dyeing practices. Indeed, our respective disciplines had diverse languages and criteria for understanding 'good' or 'bad' mordanting.

Paradoxes in the lab

While we worked, we also anticipated our future research on mordants as a paradox. How can we explore the historical question of what has counted as mordanting well in the laboratory space of today? There are many factors at play, from differences in accessible materials and tools to those in standards of durability.

We learned to take more seriously the working properties of the mordanting materials in this aspect as well. Though we needed to grind the oak galls for a mordant bath, for instance, they were too tough for our mortar and pestle. Our resourceful research assistant, Clara, managed to crush them underneath a stool.

Meanwhile, this experience drew our attention to the knowledge and skill required to manage a material's fit for — or resistance to — becoming a mordant.

Material engagement, across disciplines

We crushed, ground, boiled, simmered, and seeped cloth in mordants. Each of us felt the raw materials, their hardness, softness, or fineness. We all smelled the difference between the scent of plant-derived and metallic mordants. How do we each observe a difference in hardness, taste, or smell? And how, among chemists, historians, and anthropologists, do we explain these observations to each other? What questions rise from our shared sensory experiences? Why do they matter?

This is what material engagement across disciplines does; research questions are actively in the making and formulated from the ground up. Indeed, our shared sensory experiences helped us understand mordants together.

Resources

Cardon, Dominique. Natural Dyes : Sources, Tradition, Technology and Science. London: Archetype, 2007.

Haar, S., Schrader, E., & Gatewood, B. M. (2013). "Comparison of aluminum mordants on the colorfastness of natural dyes on cotton". Clothing and Textiles Research Journal 31 (2), 97-108. http://ctr.sagepub.com/content/31/2/97

Shahmoradi Ghaheh, F, Moghaddam, MK, Tehrani, M. (2021). "Comparison of the effect of metal mordants and bio-mordants on the colorimetric and antibacterial properties of natural dyes on cotton fabric". Coloration Technolology 137 (6): 689– 698. https://doi-org.proxy.library.uu.nl/10.1111/cote.12569

Koestler, R. J., R. Sheryll, and N. Indictor. (1985). “Identification of Dyeing Mordants and Related Substances on Textile Fibers: A Preliminary Study Using Energy Dispersive X-Ray Spectrometry.” Studies in Conservation 30 (6): 58–62. https://doi.org/10.2307/1506089

Stasińska, Katarzyna (2021). "Before They Dyed. Mordants and Assists in the Textile Dyeing Process in Anglo-Saxon and Anglo-Scandinavian Britain: An Experimental Approach". EXARC Journal (4). https://exarc.net/ark:/88735/10603



Credits

Participants: DURARE: Marjolijn Bol, Grace Kim-Butler, Jan van Daal, Henrike Scholten, Clara Mikellides de Chiaro. AlchemEast: Giacomo Montanari

The ERC DURARE project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme (grant agreement no. 852732).

The ERC AlchemEast project has received funding from the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme (GA n. 724914).

Image credits:

Photography: DURARE team

Painting of the Dyer Fritz Coler (dated 1529), Landauer Twelve Brother's House manuscript (Nuremberg, Nuremberg City Library, Germanic National Museum, Amb 279.2 ° Folio 20 (Landauer I)

Illustration in Book 19 (folio 269) of the 1482 French translation of Bartholomeus Anglicus' De proprietatibus rerum (On the Properties of Things), (London, British Library, Royal 15 E II, British).

Paper Etching, Jan Luyken's ‘De Verver’, in Het Menselyk Bedryf 1694, Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam

Seventeenth-Century Indian export cloth, Art Institute Chicago

Illustration from Georgius Acricola's De Re Metallica 1556 (ed. 1950), p. 571, Internet Archive

Reseda luteola, Wikimedia commons

Please cite as: DURARE Project (Marjolijn Bol, Jan van Daal, Grace Kim-Butler, Henrike Scholten, and Clara Mikellides de Chiaro) and Giacomo Montanari. 2023. "Hands-On with Textile Mordants: More than Meets the Eye." Last updated: 1 November 2023. https://story.durare.eu/hands-on-with-textile-mordants.